No Place for Hate

John Patterson | 3 min read

Debate is more than just a clash of arguments. It’s a space for ideas to be tested, voices to be heard, and minds to grow. But that space only works when it's rooted in mutual respect. As competitors, judges, coaches, and organizers, we must recognize one truth: there is no place for hate in debate.

Too often, debaters—especially those from marginalized communities—face microaggressions, implicit bias, and even outright discrimination. Whether it’s a dismissive comment about someone’s accent, the misgendering of a speaker, or assumptions made based on race or background, these moments chip away at what debate is supposed to stand for.

Let’s be clear: debate is not just about “free speech.” It’s about constructive speech. That means holding ourselves and each other accountable for the words we choose and the impact they have. Being provocative isn’t the same as being disrespectful. Raising tough issues isn’t the same as attacking someone's identity. And being passionate isn’t a license to ignore empathy.

Judges, you set the tone in the room. Every time you reward inclusive, thoughtful advocacy, you're shaping the future of this activity. Every time you call out inappropriate behavior or provide feedback about tone and respect, you're modeling what excellence should look like.

Coaches and captains, you’re the first line of culture-setting. Your words during team meetings, your approach to feedback, and the values you emphasize—all of these ripple outward. Make equity training a priority. Encourage your students to listen as well as speak. Normalize discussions about ethics and identity in prep rooms, not just strategy and impact calculus.

And debaters, never forget that your words hold power—not just on the ballot, but in the hearts of those who hear them. When you speak, ask yourself: am I uplifting the conversation or tearing it down? Am I building bridges or reinforcing walls?

No one is asking for sanitized debate. But we are demanding a principled one. One where people don’t have to choose between their safety and their love for the game. One where your identity isn’t a disadvantage, but a source of strength and insight. One where winning doesn't come at the cost of someone else's dignity.

Debate should challenge us, yes—but it should also empower us. It should be a place where we learn not only how to argue, but how to advocate with compassion, clarity, and courage.

So let’s make it simple: hate has no home here. Not in our rounds. Not in our prep rooms. Not in our judging paradigms. And certainly not in our community.

We owe it to each other—and to the future of this activity—to stand for something better.