Maybe It Was Never Bad Luck: Coaching Inequality

Sep 30, 2026

Sophia Ghebrelul | 4 min read

SUMMARY: This piece explains how undercoached debate students face disadvantages that go beyond simply having less help with debate. Through personal experiences with unreliable coaching and unequal access to institutional knowledge and opportunities, it examines how wealthy and well-supported programs gain advantages while underfunded teams are left to build their own support systems. The story argues that debate organizations should create stronger mentorship networks, centralize opportunities, and connect established programs with undercoached teams so that students do not have to become their own coaches just to have a chance at success.

Last year, my debate team made a running joke that our coach was a “bad luck charm.” Whenever our coach was involved, something seemed to go wrong. Tournament fees were paid late. Flights became stressful. We were left figuring out logistics ourselves. Eventually, we started joking that the safest way to ensure a successful tournament was simply to keep our coach away from it. But the more I thought about it, the less funny the joke became. For many debaters, a coach is someone who stands behind them before a round: helping with prep, calming their nerves, and opening doors to opportunities. But for others, having a coach on paper does not mean having one in practice.

“Are you guys supposed to be working this hard?” A novice asked me that last year while two varsity members and I were teaching debate class. Our coach was in his office watching SNL. By then, we had gotten used to it. We figured out tournament logistics, taught ourselves new formats, and accepted our coach's incompetence as normal. Until I realized it wasn't. Students without consistent coaching don't just become debaters. They become coaches, travel coordinators, fundraisers, and teachers. Debate is already demanding, but for some teams, preparation doesn't begin with cutting cards or writing cases. It begins with figuring out whether they can even get to the tournament.

And sometimes, the consequences were almost comical. At NSDA Nationals, our coach lost his wallet. He forced students to search his hotel room and car, becoming angry when some of us waited in the car instead of immediately joining the search. While another debater and I rummaged through his hotel room, he sat in a chair directing us: “It's not there.” “They already checked there.” I found it lodged behind the refrigerator in two minutes. We stayed at the hotel for three extra hours. At some point, you have to stop asking whether your coach is helping you and start asking: am I the debater, or am I the adult in this situation? The difference becomes especially obvious at tournaments.

At Texas State, I remember walking out of rounds and watching my opponents immediately gather around their coaches. They received feedback, discussed what went wrong, and prepared for whatever came next. Then there was us. I remember staying up late at the beginning of my LD career, trying to fill in the craters of knowledge my coach had left open. The inequality isn't about who works harder. In fact, undercoached students often work harder simply to reach the same starting line.

A good coach provides more than instruction. They provide institutional knowledge. They know which tournaments exist, when applications are due, which camps have scholarships, and who students should contact. You cannot apply for an opportunity you were never told existed. And perhaps that's the worst kind of bad luck: losing a race you never knew you were running. But this problem is bigger than one incompetent coach.

A 2022 study found that 82.35% of independent and private schools offered debate compared to only 24.31% of public schools (Jacques et al). The issue isn't that private-school debaters are inherently more talented. Talent develops differently when one student has institutional support while another has to build that infrastructure themselves. Experienced coaches, resources, and institutional knowledge become concentrated in wealthy programs while underfunded teams are left trying to catch up. 

The solution isn't to blame every individual coach. Many coaches are teachers working unpaid hours with little institutional support. A Vanderbilt study on coaching burnout found that public school debate coaches are under extreme structural strain. They are expected to balance heavy teaching loads with minimal institutional funding, little to no supplemental stipend pay, and grueling year-round travel schedules. As veteran coaches retire under this exhaustion, underfunded schools struggle to find successors, reinforcing the inequality gap against more stable private school infrastructures. Instead, debate needs stronger mentorship networks connecting experienced coaches and alumni with undercoached teams. (Keller, 2025) Opportunities like camps, scholarships, and tournaments should be centralized instead of hidden behind personal connections. Established programs should partner with coachless and underfunded teams. Because debate constantly tells students to be resourceful. And students without coaches have certainly learned how to be. But resilience should not be a requirement for access.

So maybe our coach was never actually a bad luck charm. Maybe we called it bad luck because it was easier than admitting that, in debate, access to support is often left up to chance. The biggest inequality in debate isn't who has the most talented students. It's who has access to the people, resources, and opportunities that turn talent into success. And no student should have to become their own coach just to have a chance at competing. This version is much tighter and relies more on showing the problem through your actual experiences rather than repeatedly explaining the same inequality.

The Debate Hotline

The Debate Hotline

The Debate Hotline

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.