Balancing Music and Debate

Sep 30, 2026

Joshua Segraves| 9 min read

SUMMARY: How do you manage two of the busiest worlds that high schoolers can enter? Music and debate intersect not only in the skills they offer, but also because many auditions and tournaments can conflict. Both activities strive to make us better, more creative people. The way we approach their demands is similarly creative.

I once had to choose between a TOC bid and playing the famous Daphnis et Chloé suite. This experience taught me a lot about how to handle the intensive activities of music and debate. The audition season may be shorter than the debate season, but both can be equally troubling. As a dedicated cellist and PF debater, it can be difficult to find a balance. Tournaments often line up with rehearsals and concerts. All-State could be on the same day as TOC. Often, there’s the dilemma of committing an evening to cutting prep or practicing. Ultimately, in my experience, I have found a number of strategies to be successful in both fields. And it is possible! Debate is an art in and of itself, and it teaches us skills that are transferable to music, school, and other art forms. It teaches us performance, efficient practice, and being okay with not doing our best one day. I will do my best to share my story and my thoughts, but a great cello teacher of mine said, “Everything is theoretical until you get on the stage.” It truly comes down to the moment and what you choose to do with it.

First, I want to tell you of a hard decision I had to make. In my sophomore year, there was a weekend in February where I had two back-to-back weekend concerts at the same time as the Bellaire Forensic Tournament. I knew that if I went to Bellaire, I could easily get a bid to the TOC. I knew that if I played in the concerts, I would have the performance of a lifetime with one of the best pieces in the orchestral repertoire (namely Daphnis et Chloé). I chose the concerts, not because I didn’t value debate, but because at that moment I knew that the concert would be more meaningful to me. It was an incredibly hard decision, and I had to consult my parents, my debate partner, and teachers. I envisioned what both worlds would have looked like. To me, it meant more to play a piece that I very well might never see again rather than possibly lose at Bellaire. Funnily enough, I encountered the Daphnis only a few months later at a summer camp. I want to go over some concrete pillars that have helped navigate this journey but I think the best advice I have is that both worlds are fun. They come off as stressful, and they are, but they are also rewarding. You really aren’t making the wrong choice either way. Balance doesn't mean giving everything equal time. Balance means knowing what deserves your time at a given moment.

  1. Understanding Your Limits

You cannot do it all, and that is okay. We often go into activities with expectations that are way too high. We sometimes cannot perfect that one hard 16th note passage, and we will not always bid at tournaments. I think the main culprit is comparison. We are our own harshest critic of our flaws, yes, but we do that relative to people we think are better than us. I might watch a child prodigy play my solo. I might spectate TOC Finals and say I’d get demolished in a heartbeat. But remember, no activity demands perfection. It only demands progress. That is not possible if you overload yourself with activities and events. We lose the fun in the process by getting overwhelmed.

A lot of times, people will say they can go the extra mile. They can lose one night’s sleep to practice or cut. This reality is both true and false. We will need to make sacrifices and work hard if we want to tackle both fields. We will probably lose a lot of sleep and be tired consistently. But not everyone has the same physical or mental limits. That is up to you to find out and to keep yourself from crossing those lines. Always establish boundaries well in advance so that in the moment, those crazy decisions can be made with even an inch of extra precision.

  1. Managing Stress

The biggest piece of advice I can give for when times get tough is to breathe, take a step back, and re-organize. It is easier said than done, but when done comprehensively, it is effective. I, like many, have horrible audition and performance nerves. I get into a room, and I go ice-cold, my heartbeat pounds into the back of my cello, and I feel like I’ve forgotten how to play. I step into a bubble round, and my hands are shaking. What could I possibly do? Breathe. I have been very fortunate to have a lot of mentors that have given me great exercises. For me, I deliberately slow my breathing, sometimes using 4-7-8 breathing or humming quietly to myself. Regardless, come up with a method to self-regulate. 

In the heat of the moment, we let our brains hyperfixate. We get so worked up about what we are about to do that we lose sight of everything else. Literally ask yourself, “Why am I here again? What am I doing?” Give yourself room to think about it and recall that you are incredibly talented. You might not have the record to prove it yet (if you are reading this early in your career), but you still have worth, and you have proven yourself to people. This audition or this debate round isn’t a chance to prove yourself. Your preparation is evidence that you belong in the room; the performance is simply one more data point. Everyone will have a terrible performance one day and an incredible run the next day. But one thing I seek to do actively in my preparation is to train my weakest day to not be so bad. That way, when I inevitably perform poorly, it won’t actually be so devastating. If there is a run in my solo repertoire that is really hard and I’ll probably mess it up, I practice it until I have at least 9/10 accuracy. Recall whatever you need to motivate yourself and remember that at the end of the day, neither a bad round nor a bad audition is going to determine the rest of your life. When the activities are structurally correct, they can only offer you more, not less.

Similar to the last part, you must reorganize yourself. You cannot expect to get anywhere by panicking. You know how you experience nerves and stress, so take time to craft an approach. The anxiety I face on stage versus in the debate room is very different. Set out a plan for the next time you go off the rails. Rely on your friends and family to recenter you. Make sure you have concrete steps for going through the next round or the next concert. All of this so far seems helpful if it’s just a day of auditions or just the time of the debate tournament. What about when you are stressing about picking the two? Same thing: breathe, step back, and reorganize. 

  1. Balanced Routines

“The practice room is a laboratory.” I’ve heard this phrase a thousand times. But it really matters. We always praise the actual tournament or the concert, but it really is the journey that gets us there. The reason we find the decision between going to one event or another is that we put in a lot of time and effort, and we don’t want it to go to waste. To assure ourselves that it doesn’t, we must craft our time in practice rounds and solo practice carefully. Budget time to achieve a skill level that you are satisfied with. That split might look like 1 hour of music and 2 hours of cutting cards. Whatever it is, tailor it to your interests but also your capabilities. I know I could practice cello non-stop for a much longer time than I could focus on cutting cards. (Maybe that has to do with being on a computer, and YouTube is one click away)

If you are unsure about what will work for you, consult teachers, parents, and friends. I have spoken to my debate coach and my cello private lesson teacher multiple times about balancing my commitment. They know you better than you think and can offer real insights. Often, they are the ones who will notice when you aren’t putting in the most effort you could. But why are they so stringent? Because they know you can do it. It takes being open to that conversation to get that ball rolling. I have also chatted with my debate partner and with music friends when times get tough.

  1. Having Fun

Both worlds are small and communal. Everyone wants to, hopefully, see everyone else grow. Simply because we all value the activities for being educational, important, personal, and fun. Even after making a hard choice, I try to just enjoy the experience of another high-stakes debate tournament or a long, challenging concert. Maybe I’ll do really badly and not have a good time, but that’s okay. We aren’t necessarily doing these activities to be perfect at them. Our highest performance can never become our benchmark. It’s unrealistic. We do these things because we have a passion and we believe they matter. So truly, have fun with it. When you mess up, laugh it off. Nobody cares. If I could, I’d use harsher language to illustrate my point. Nobody wants to see perfection; they want to see your drive. We don’t watch amazing debate rounds just to learn, but because we are in awe of their commitment and energy. We don’t simply revel in recordings of Yo Yo Ma or Hilary Hahn because they are technically genius, but because they are musical and emotional. Such levels of maturity, of course, come from honing in on skills, foundations, and technique. But if you lack such depth, then this field of art becomes “meh.” We lose the enjoyment, the fulfillment, and the point of it all.

I don’t think that music and debate will ever have a perfect middle ground. I don’t think that any strategy will entirely satisfy you. You will lose out on practice time, concerts, tournaments, hangouts, etc. But the balance I strive for is knowing what matters to me when those moments come—and being at peace with the choice I make. Either way, I’m lucky to have two things that are worth choosing and are worth the sacrifice.

The Debate Hotline

The Debate Hotline

The Debate Hotline

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.